May 15, 2012

A hidden gem: Utopia Cafe


The back seating area at Utopia
A few weeks ago, 2 of my foodie friends (C &S) and I went to Utopia Café , located at 586 College Street West, in Toronto. S promised an evening of amazing nachos and delectable poutine. Lucky for us, he did not disappoint.

Tofu Cream Croquettes
Small and very unassuming, Utopia looks like it would fit perfectly in an episode of Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives (Canadian edition, anyone)? From poutine to burgers to their version of Tex-mex, Utopia boasts a huge menu with lots of variety. Normally, I find big menus don’t always deliver, as most places only have a few dishes they really excel at.  Randomly trying a few dishes (and because S INSISTS that anything and everything he’s ever had has been pure genius), I was pleasantly surprised that Utopia does deliver.

We started the meal off with Tofu Cream Croquettes, crispy panko croquettes of fresh tofu and cream cheese served with a spicy chipotle BBQ sauce.  We ordered (well, I may have demanded) these on a whim, after all, tofu and cream cheese have drastically different textures…which means the croquettes had to be amazing or a complete train wreck. Luckily, they were amazing. The texture was soft and the taste mild, while the bbq sauce added just the right amount of zing.

Veggie Nachos
We then ordered the Veggie Nachos (freshly made corn tortilla chips piled high and topped with a blend of melted cheeses, spicy salsa, jalapeño peppers, white beans, tofu, corn and sour cream) – they didn’t disappoint either. The freshly made chips were definitely the star, and while I’m not a fan of white beans, they were actually quite tasty. Even the texture couldn’t weird me out.

Gourmet Poutine
By this point, we were full (but not FULL), so we pushed our luck and ordered one more dish: the Gourmet Poutine (sautéed mushrooms, goat cheese and veggie gravy). Now, I’m not a fan of goat cheese (or strong cheeses in general), but the cheese was very mild and gave some great flavour and texture contrast (I’m not a food snob at all).  It acted almost like a sour cream.

Let’s just say we made quick work of the poutine and then some.

S swears that everything on the menu is delicious…I cannot wait to go back and help prove him right.

Restaurant rating: Definitely worth an extra hour or two at the gym.